When a Publication is Being a D***head


A few months ago I forged a connection with a fellow writer/journalist online. She became a very good e-friend, and when she found out that I write features and commentaries for publication, she asked me if I would write for her. Turns out that she’s the editor of a newspaper based in California and was interested in an essay I wrote here.

I happily reworked the piece to better fit the needs of an op-ed column and sent it in. That was the beginning of a very productive and professional relationship that included more features and editorials over the next few weeks.

When she subsequently left the paper, I wasn’t too worried. Her successor was happy to work with me, so I continued the relationship. I pitched ideas, the editor liked (or not) and approved (or not) them.

Very recently, however, that editor abruptly left the paper. I was in limbo for a couple of days while I waited to hear from a new editor on the pieces I was still working on. I finally was able to get a hold of the new editor via telephone, who reassured me that they were still interested in my work. I said that I had one piece that I would submit at the end of this week and another I could submit the following week.

Fair enough. The editor said that the schedule was fine and that he looked forward to receiving them.

The very next day, I receive an email from a different editor informing me that because of “cost-cutting” measures at the paper, they would no longer be able to accept any of my submissions. I fired off an email asking if that included pieces I was working on already (one of which I’d been working on for a few weeks) and that had already been assigned and greenlighted by both the previous editor and the new one. The reply was Yes, it included those as well. In other words, they were terminating my services.

Moral of the story? I’m not sure there is one. Veteran freelance writers will tell you that a lot of editor-writer relationships are such that contracts are often not necessary because of the trust that’s developed over a long period of time in such a situation. The first editor with whom I worked was great, and I never felt the need to have a contract. However, given that the paper had 3 editors in the relatively brief period of time I worked with them, perhaps that should have been a clue that I was not dealing with a stable organization. In such a situation, a contract should have been the first thing I requested when my editor-friend departed and a new one took her place. I would have been spared the experience of working on an “assigned” piece and then ultimately getting booted by the paper. What they did was unprofessional and unethical (after all, verbal agreements often hold up in court, and I had email trails to prove the assignments), but that doesn’t help me recover the lost time and effort I’d invested in the articles.

What do you think?

3 thoughts on “When a Publication is Being a D***head

  1. I was a paid columnist for the Arizona Republic and signed some hideous Gannett contract a while back–but resisted querying columns…I wrote about what I wanted. Then came the day when they said, “We love this, could you post it to the web.” Oh–that would be for free. I have been screwed with contracts, screwed without–sometimes having something to shove in their face is effective, sometimes not.PS I am vision-impaired and one day will drop off the cyber map because of these little security tests–I can’t read this stuff, all smeared together to fake out some robot, to save my life…If a daughter is passing, have to ask her.

  2. Hi, <>Kristen<>! At this point, I’m done with them. At the very least, I have several great clips I can use to add to my pile. Something about lemons becoming lemonade.Dear <>Star<>, I don’t query columns. The ones I wrote for this publication actually arose from a request by the previous editors to submit a commentary on a particular event (e.g., the California primary). I generally pitched features. Lately I’ve been focusing more on the regular, paid column I do have for the local paper. It doesn’t pay much, but it’s steady work, and the assignment is super. I’m so sorry about the anti-spam device on the blog! I’m concerned about spam, but I’ll experiment with removing that and see how it goes. Thanks for the heads-up!Cheers,Marjorie

Comments are closed.